清空播放记录
播放地址
猜你喜欢
剧照
详细剧情
长篇影评
1 ) 【随影笔记】补一点英国政治
——Backbench (backbenchers)后座议员——
Backbenchers are MPs or members of the House of Lords that are neither government ministers nor opposition Shadow spokespeople. They are so called because, in the Chamber, they sit in the rows of benches behind their parties' spokespeople who are known as frontbenchers.
<图片2>
Traditionally, backbenchers were called 'private members'; when a bill is introduced by a backbencher it is still described as a Private Member's Bill.
How effective are Backbenchers in the House of Commons?
While backbenchers are having more of an influence in recent years, they are rarely effective at forming a resistance to the power of the executive, and thus they are really limited in their effectiveness in shaping world events.
From 2010 to March 2015, the government has only been defeated 7 times in the Commons. However the few defeats are often significant- for example the 2013 Syrian civil war motion was defeated by 30 Tory rebel MPS and this in turn stopped the US going to war- seriously affecting global geopolitics in the Middle East.
——By-elections 补选——
A UK Parliamentary by-election takes place when a seat in the House of Commons becomes vacant between general elections. 一种非常规选举，只在议会内有遗缺时进行，以补回空缺议席的余下任期。选新议员期间，其选区事务由相邻选区同一党派的议员代理。（有遗缺原因：有议员辞职/破产/患精神疾病/严重刑事犯罪/死亡）
'Moving the Writ'
Traditionally the Chief Whip of the political party whose MP held the vacant seat will begin the procedure for a by-election. This is known as 'moving the Writ' and takes the form of a motion in the House of Commons.
<图片3>
——marginal constituency 边缘选区——
也叫marginal seat/swing seat: a constituency held with a small majority in a legislative election. 各党(或者竞争的主要两党)得票很接近的选区，因此竞争激烈，竞选活动主要开展在这里。美国相对应的概念是摇摆州（Swing state，也称游离州、战场州或紫州）。非摇摆州也称安全州(safe state)，因为某候选人已有足够支持，可以安全赢得该州选票。
Targeting: the concentration of money and manpower in areas where they will make the most difference. 目标竞选：把资金和人力集中在最可能有所作为的地区。
在英国，英格兰中部（Midlands）的边缘选区往往是竞选活动关注的焦点，而不是萨里（保守党选区）或英格兰东北部（工党选区）。05年大选时，自民党把目光瞄准保守党的边缘选区，但这种“斩首策略”（"decapitation" strategy）并未奏效。
在美国大选中，选举团（Electoral College）实行“胜者全得”制（the winner-takes-all System），即把本州的选举人票全部给予在该州获得相对多数普选票的总统候选人，因此竞选资源也多集中于摇摆州。
Pork barreling：The creation of policy that will benefit a particular seat, at the expense of other taxpayers. 政治分肥大多采取直接对某地区或某企业拨款的方法，是争取边缘选区的策略之一。pork barrel一词来源于美国，是攻击竞选对手用的贬义词，在英国叫sweetener, 或election sweetener, tax sweetener. Yes, Minister里有提到过。
资料来源：
Parliament glossary-Backbench (backbenchers)
How effective are Backbenchers in the House of Commons
补选-维基百科
Parliament glossary-By-elections
上议院和下议院
摇摆州-维基百科
政治分肥-维基百科
Marginal seat-wiki
2 ) BBC's take on Yes, Minister
Three series were made between 1980 and 1984, before Jim Hacker achieved real power in Yes Prime Minister.
<图片2>
The series follows Right Honorable James Hacker MP, Minister for Administrative Affairs, and his attempts to make officialdom and administration make sense. He does this whilst pushing his own self-serving agenda, and keeping his head above any nasty political waters. Throughout his career, he's up against Whitehall’s Sir Humphrey Appleby, unflappable symbol of a machine that has no gears, only brakes.
Jim's policies, whether cutting costs or trying to streamline red tape, are sabotaged by Appleby's Machiavellian skills, often accompanied by brain-wrenching sentences designed to confuse Hacker - and often succeeding. Absolutely snobbish and elitist, yet blind to anything that does not serve the Whitehall way, Sir Humphrey is the avatar of the British State.
<图片3>
Hacker's politics appear to be completely pragmatic and blown by the winds of chance, and are never dogmatic enough to be clearly labelled Labour or Conservative. By removing the trappings of a particular 'party' and allowing both sides to appear at their worst - venal and inconstant Hacker forever opposing the pompous and manipulative Appleby - Yes, Minister maintained a timeless quality that means it has endured beyond the Thatcherite politics it satirised.
Issues were raised that are still timely now - identity papers and computer databases of the population, university funding, arms sales, oil politics being just a few.
<图片4>
Motifs of the series included the wonderful music of Ronnie Hazelhurst playing against Gerald Scarfe's hilarious caricatures of the three leads; Hacker's use of catastrophically mixed metaphors, his Private Secretary Bernard's fondness for awful puns and maddening pedantry, and Sir Humphrey's laconic wit, almost shocking contempt for anyone who isn't a senior Civil Servant, and his catchphrase, usually after totally defeating Hacker, of muttering 'Yes Minster' to close the show.
<图片5>
Whilst the iconic figure of Sir Humphrey, as portrayed by Nigel Hawthorne, is the series' enduring legacy, the true star of the show is Hacker, as played by Paul Eddington. Though most of the verbal quips are Humphrey's, the comedy is Hacker's, mainly because Paul Eddington was probably the best comedy actor of his generation and his timing is miraculous.
Always buffeted by fate, wanting to do good but too scared of losing votes and status to do anything, Hacker is the symbol of all of us, wanting to be better, and not quite making it.
A true original, Yes Minister remains one of the most influential sitcoms of its time, as witness its huge success, many awards (including BAFTAs for the show and for Hawthorne).
<图片6>
Famously accurate in the spirit of the relationship between civil servant and politician, it was Mrs Thatcher's favourite show... make of that whatever you want. Yes Minister was proof that comedy could take on serious subjects and make real points with them.
搬运自BBC-Comedy Yes, Minister
3 ) 你可能不知道的Yes, Minister
搬运自 imdb The writers had advisors who had worked within the government and many of the stories were based on real situations. For example, in Yes Minister: The Moral Dimension (1982) they go to an arab state where alcohol is not allowed and so they set up a "communications room" in the embassy where they keep a stash of booze so they could slip out and have a drink. This really happened.
A great fan of the series, Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher (as she then was) wrote a sketch for the show with press secretary Bernard Ingham which was recorded and aired as part of the 1984 National Viewers and Listeners Awards. The sketch featured Paul Eddington and Nigel Hawthorne, both of whom are talking to the Prime Minister (played by Thatcher herself) about her notion to abolish economists. The role of James Hacker was written with Paul Eddington in mind. Only three episodes in the series - Yes Minister: The Economy Drive (1980); Yes Minister: Big Brother (1980); and Yes Minister: The Right to Know (1980) - did not end with the phrase "Yes Minister." Paul Eddington, Nigel Hawthorne and Derek Fowlds all hated having to record the show in front of a studio audience (as was the convention for television sitcoms at the time) due to the distraction and often having to pause for audience laughter to die down. Screenwriters Antony Jay and Jonathan Lynn avoided all references that could indicate Hacker's political party, though Lynn later admitted they had always imagined him as a centre minded Conservative.
Ronnie Hazlehurst's theme-tune is composed around the chimes of Big Ben at the Palace of Westminster. The British Film Institute (BFI) named this as one of the top ten television programmes of all time.
4 ) E05，哈克和首相相互背刺，相互甩锅，精彩！太精彩了！
制定国民综合交通政策，因为牵扯多方利益，不管怎么做都是得罪人不讨好，成了没人接的烫手山芋，甚至连交通部长都坚决不干。
于是两位老哥选定了哈克来当这个大冤种，把这份苦差事包装成一份特殊的荣誉、一个晋升、一份礼物，并且特地避开汉弗莱，因为他们很清楚，汉弗莱肯定知道这是个大坑，不会接。
两个大忽悠的一个又一个的高帽子给哈克戴着，当听到万一这事儿办成了能拉选票，哈克毫不犹豫地选择接受这份新工作。
一回去就跟汉弗莱炫耀，不出意外，被泼了冷水：制定政策意味着做决策，只会取悦受惠人，同时也得罪了其他的所有人。
“赢得1票，丢掉10票”，哈克还是不死心，万一这事儿成了呢？于是汉弗莱召集交通部的三位副秘书（公路局、铁路局、航空部门），先安排一次预备会议。
经过一番菜市场吵架般的会议，哈克终于明白了：哦，原来我是大冤种！
于是哈克的「杀手本能」觉醒：把首相的选区作为试点！（妙！）
1️⃣在公园建设公交站，因为公园靠近火车站，让火车站和公交站建在一起
2️⃣合并公交维修站和铁路维修站，美其名曰省钱
3️⃣通勤者全额支付票价
4️⃣所有公交车18:30收班
5️⃣公交站原址建集装箱卡车停车场
5层buff 叠加，首相看了估计牙都要咬碎。
为了显示对首相的「忠诚」，哈克准备提前给首相提交一份草案，还顺带贴心地为每一位内阁同僚打印一份，这样就算「一不小心遗失一份给媒体」，也无从查起了。
于是乎，汉弗莱这么凑巧地约了《泰晤士报》的记者吃晚饭。🥹
可想而知，5层buff叠加，再加上直接泄密给媒体，首相坐在办公室都要咬碎牙。
然而，首相也不是吃素的！在自己选区的报纸上宣告，“你们别慌，这已经被我否决了”。并且还报道，哈克就是新任命的“交通总管”。
已经指定哈克为新的交通总管，然而哈克还没收到正式通知，「据悉」这俩字儿就用的很妙，首相的任命媒体是怎么知道的呢？首相这边给出的理由是：泄密，途径暂且不论，内容确实是真实的。
显然，哈克被首相摆了一道。皮球又踢回来了。
于是，汉弗莱开始发动技能了：
如果不能做出一个让每个人都满意的方案，那就做一个坑死所有人的方案，让他们主动来否决你，主动把你踢出去，这样你就能全身而退！
汉弗莱早就拟出了草案，哈克还要把摘要发给记者，甚至不用担心泄密调查，就算调查也是做做样子，不可能真的查出来是谁泄密，因为，大部分泄密都是从唐宁街10号开始的🥺
果不其然，首相这边开始用泄密唬哈克。
然而，哈克在当大臣之前，是干媒体的，这属于是专业对口了🤣
但是阿诺德哪能这么轻易低头，坚持说调查「第一次泄密」才是首要任务，哈克反击，调查唐宁街10号泄密的可能性才更重要。阿诺德难得吃瘪。
哈克顺带说起，由于泄密事件，公众难免抗议，让行政部更难制定交通政策。
阿诺德顺着台阶而下，那要不还是还给交通部好了。哈克和汉弗莱还要装木作样恭维两句哈哈哈哈哈
事情都解决了，还咬着泄密不放，那怎么办？要不建议首相发起一次泄密调查？（哈哈哈哈哈
哈克说有办法处理泄密时，都身体前倾凑一块儿听，当听到哈克的「好办法」后，战术性后仰的名场面🥹
5 ) 21世纪依然没有被超越的最佳政治喜剧
两年看了七遍的程度。
大二的时候在学校每天下午下了课回宿舍，泡面/面包/零食/水果然后打开播放器。
交换的时候教印度政治的老师上课说她也喜欢Yes, prime minister我差点冲上讲台跟她握手的程度。她说那个内阁秘书长叫啥，Sir啥，我大喊Sir Hamphrey!
后来有翻拍过新版，但老版实在太深入人心了，太经典了🌟
6 ) 透过现象看复读机本质——《是，大臣第3季》
今天聊聊英剧《是，大臣第3季》。
片名Yes Minister Season 3 (1982)，别名遵命，部长 / 部长大人(台)。
《是，大臣》第三季中詹姆斯·乔治·哈克大臣（James George Hacker）继续和汉弗莱·阿普尔比爵士（Sir Humphrey Appleby）斗智斗勇，顺带着可爱的伯纳（Bernard）在旁边冷冷吐槽。
哈克大臣代表的是职业政客，阿普尔比和伯纳代表的是职业公务员，两方根本利益不同，但也因为身处同一个部门而在宏观上处于利益共同体。双方除了较劲外，更多还是以把自己的蛋糕做大为根本。
在编导的带领下，观众们得以透过现象看本质，这些话看起来匪夷所思，细细一想却都是话糙理不糙。
随意摘几句对话都是经典，这里说的都是英国。
“如果政府不行善，那它的目的是什么？”
“大臣，政府不关乎善与恶，只关乎治与乱。”
“公务员工作三原则：越拖延越高效，越费钱越便宜，越秘密越民主。”
“规划调查员不是独立的吗？”
“是的，大臣。当然，火车也是独立的，只要铺好轨道，他们照样跟着走。”
“反正工业部长也整天做无用功。”
“教育部长没教养。”
“就业部长该失业。”
“算了，我们只好绝不松口，反咬回去。”
“如果您不松口的话就没办法咬回去。”
《是，大臣》第三季最后一集长达1小时，而且可能是电视史上唯一一个同时作为系列结局、圣诞特辑、系列组合故事过渡集、后续系列试播集的剧集了。
汉弗莱·阿普尔比爵士经过举荐，首先接任首相秘书，入驻唐宁街10号，紧接着首相宣布下台，党内继续推选一个新首相。
在两个党内候选人相互比烂的情况下，走中间路线的詹姆斯·乔治·哈克捡了个大便宜，成功当上了首相。当然，哈克不忘带上伯纳，继续做自己的私人秘书。
这样，三人的故事将在《是，首相》（Yes Prime Minister）中继续上演。
人类的本质是复读机，说起来以史为鉴，而实际上都是在不断重复已经发生过的事情。
当年《是，大臣》就表现出预言特质，吉姆·哈克突然崛起为新首相的过程颇为戏剧化，但几年后现实世界给出了印证，1990年约翰·梅杰（John Major）捡漏当选英国首相，和哈克当上首相有着许多相似之处。
不限于此，《是，大臣》揭露的政府运作“内幕”未来被不断提及、验证，剧中一针见血地揭开政府运作真相。
所谓为民服务只是利益集团敛财的幌子，民主监督、新闻监督也只是利益交换的筹码，不论哪个人都可以被收买，出价者只要能够找准核心利益进行交换，就能把对方拿捏地死死的。
嘴巴跟着屁股走，每个人所处的位置决定了他的行为。政客关心的是选票，公务员关心的是自己的收益，双方会用各种手段粉饰自己的行为，而本质则不会有丝毫改变。
《是，大臣》的编剧里就有在政府工作的顾问，因此剧中的很多故事都是基于真实事件，并不是凭空想象的。
例如，在第三季第4集《道德维度》就源自真实事件，哈克他们去了一个禁止饮酒的阿拉伯国家，于是这些酒鬼在大使馆里设立了一个“交流室”，在里面存放酒水，时不时地溜进去喝一杯。真实情况发生在1978年他们出访巴基斯坦的时候。
《是，大臣》当年播出时好评如潮，英国议员甚至会为了回家看剧而翘班早退。
英国首相玛格丽特·撒切尔（Margaret Thatcher）与新闻秘书伯纳德·英厄姆（Bernard Ingham）同样也是本剧的铁杆粉丝，还一起为该节目写了一个小段子，并邀请剧中两位主角保罗·爱丁顿和奈杰尔·霍桑一起出演，在节目中大家一起谈论她废除经济学家的想法。
然而，保罗·爱丁顿和奈杰尔·霍桑并不想出演，但还是被迫参加节目……
问渠哪得清浊五色各异，
透过现象看复读机本质。
这里是硬核影迷集散地，欢迎关注公众号：妙看影视
圣诞特别篇真是首尾呼应的典范，既呼应了本集开头给Bernard的surprise，也呼应了本剧第一季第一集的phone jitters. 只是首相突然提早离职的安排也太奇怪了。
笑死了笑死了，必须起身鼓掌送给这群老头，真是太有趣了，好高端漂亮的英文词汇句子啊。恭喜haker成为了10号!!!!!!9.8分!!!果然是神剧
《THE WHISKY PRIEST》这一集系列最佳，以前看的话我应会流泪。
期待唐宁街10号再见~以后碰到说话绕弯的人就这么问"You're not related to Sir Humphrey Appleby by any chance?" 另外，Bernard越来越可爱了~
在遇见这剧之前我从来不知道世界上居然拍这种题材能有这么个拍法的(以前更加孤陋寡闻嗯），人物塑造各种对话单独挑哪里出来都是一等一的赞，萌爆了的剧（等等
完美的“大臣奋斗三部曲”，从第一季刚进内阁不了解情况、被秘书玩弄于股掌之间，到第二季熟悉规则、有时还利用秘书反击一下，这第三季算是修得圆满、与秘书配合默契并同化了，互相掩护、打官腔也熟练不少、对官僚运作机制了解颇深。而私人秘书伯纳虽然也适应了两面派生活，但经常抛书袋，没多少长进。
这剧本，这表演，这从句套从句套从句套从句的表达。。。= = 三位主演两位已逝，只有Bernard一人看新版YM是如何糟蹋经典的。
第七集绝了，民膏民脂供有权有势的人享乐
一集一集看下来真的是非常过瘾，而且越陷越深...所谓神剧和经典的确有它的魔力，如今很火的《House of cards》一集就看不下去了，感谢这部剧，让我一个政治盲得到了启蒙。无可救药的爱上这部剧了，不因为它到底有多搞笑，而是看着它就给人很惬意温馨的感觉。三个人都好可爱，特别是Bernard好萌！！！2021.9二刷，大概从第三集开始非常赞了！
這一季的服裝很不錯。Humpy往事被揭露簡直太經典，Bernard充分發掘了自己的潛力，Hacker的學習成果得到了導師的肯定XD
1.女性主义；2. 精简冗余公务员、民防工程与“领导先躲”&媒体“自由” 3. 打压高效地方政府&掩盖历史失责档案 4. 公务员蹭出国&外贸行贿订单&公务员家属受贿；5. 陆运空运铁路-公共交通；6.军火与恐怖分子&道德真空；7.花大部分老百姓的税补贴少数精英趣味（歌剧院音乐厅美术馆等）还是大部分老百姓的平民娱乐
第一集的女权问题放到三十年后的今天也是最常被谈论的话题，而在1900的精讲里，弹幕里男人的反驳和跳脚和坐在会议室里的英国老白男如出一辙，感觉什么都没有变，什么都没有解决，哪有什么矫枉过正，争取权利就是进十退九。
太机智了！连Bernard半真半假的回答都闪耀着智慧的光芒！嘤~
打岔的艺术、下套的艺术、扯皮的艺术、装傻的艺术、捅娄子的艺术、补锅的艺术……
这后面几集伯纳德戏份越来越多，也越来越智慧了，不过伯纳德衰老得好快！汉弗莱确实魅力四射虽说并不是啥善人。最后哈克给伯纳德升官，汉弗莱不高兴，估计是觉得他俩关系太近了吧。
除了关于性别问题的那集笑不出来外 其他还是好好笑啊:D
都是些道德中空的人，不过因为自己的良心而否定他人的道德未免太过了，所以我们要做的事是什么也不理，做自己职责内的事罢了PS难得有三人“合作”简直不是棒字了得，开始喜欢狡诈却明智的Humphey了，大臣真的很萌
minister想把Bernard当弃子给扔掉的时候我可伤心了！！！(╬￣皿￣)凸虽然Bernard总是墙头草两边倒，可是人家总是尽力帮助minister你呢！！怎么还不如humpy对Bernard 呢！(╬￣皿￣)凸还好最好Bernard的事情被压下来了！
三星半。特别篇的条目找不到了及写在这儿吧~ jim还是成功上位了啊！！ 经过了这么多事儿你说jim真什么都不知道吗？真傻吗？切~凭我的智商反正是做不到他这个程度~最后游说竞选人的部分赶脚jim超有范儿啊~干脆利落！等着你呦PM~
可能是这辈子看到的最好的剧了吧